Arts news
The Fantasticks finally reaches Broadway, with two boys at its heart
The Nov. 16 Broadway premiere brings Tom Jones’s revised love story to the Hayes Theater, with two mothers and an eight-piece score reshaping a familiar musical.

Sixty-six years after The Fantasticks began its New York life, the musical is scheduled to have its first Broadway opening Monday, Nov. 16. Second Stage’s production at the Hayes Theater has been in previews since Oct. 22. Its young lovers are Matt and Lewis, played by Maxim Chlumecky and Nathan Levy, and their mothers are the ones doing the matchmaking.
The revised book and lyrics are by Tom Jones, who wrote the original with composer Harvey Schmidt. Director and choreographer Christopher Gattelli is bringing that version to Broadway with a larger musical ensemble. The changes give returning audiences two things to listen for, the parents’ attempts to manage love and the sound surrounding the young men as they find it.
The mothers have to let the story get away from them
Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer plays Matt’s mother, and Ruthie Ann Miles plays Lewis’s. Their scheme gives the romance its push. The parents pretend to be enemies so that their sons will be drawn together. In a story about young people finding their own way, the adults are trying to write the ending before the boys have lived through the middle.
Kritzer and Miles discussed that tension in an Oct. 20 interview with Broadway Direct. Both found an emotional charge in “Plant a Radish,” the parents’ song about how much less predictable children are than vegetables. Kritzer described wanting to protect people while knowing that love gives no control over what happens to them. Miles spoke about letting children get hurt, make mistakes and choose whether to come home.
Those accounts suggest a way to watch the mothers when the comedy is moving fastest. A successful scheme would let them feel they had secured their sons’ futures. A successful act of parenting would also have to leave room for the boys’ own decisions. The performers’ challenge, as Miles described it, is to hold on to the clowning in the writing while making the feeling underneath it believable.
Eight players, with the harp still in the room
Music supervisor and orchestrator Sam Davis told BroadwayWorld that the Broadway accompaniment would expand to eight players. The familiar Off-Broadway sound centered on piano and harp. Davis described adding three strings and keeping the harp writing wherever possible, with the aim of making the romance fuller while retaining the show’s close scale.
That gives the expansion a point beyond volume. A string line can continue beneath a singer’s breath or carry a phrase into the next voice. For a love story now sung by two men, the way the accompaniment meets each voice matters alongside the changes to the lyrics. Davis identified that romantic quality as a priority he shared with Gattelli.
The small Hayes auditorium is part of the calculation. Davis said he wanted the Broadway version to keep the intimacy associated with the piece. For listeners who know “Soon It’s Gonna Rain,” the useful question is how the larger group supports the two singers as a pair. A familiar tune can give them an immediate reference point for hearing the new setting.

A first Broadway night after a long life elsewhere
The earlier history belongs to Off-Broadway. The original production opened in May 1960 at the Sullivan Street Playhouse and ran for 42 years. Jones and Schmidt’s own musical careers also included Broadway work such as 110 in the Shade and I Do! I Do! The first Broadway production of The Fantasticks arrives with a body of songs that audiences could already have encountered across decades of performances.
The version reaching the Hayes has its own history too. Director Michael Lluberes’ production record identifies the 2022 Flint Repertory Theatre staging as the world premiere of the LGBTQ+ reimagining. Jones worked on the rewrite with Lluberes, making the young lovers two men. Broadway’s arrival is a new stage in the life of that revision, four years after its first production.
That sequence changes what Monday’s milestone means. The musical has had time to become familiar, and this version has had time to be played. Its Broadway opening brings those two histories together in a production that asks audiences to follow a different family through the same broad question of how love grows up.
The Broadway League lists the Hayes engagement through Feb. 7, 2027. The theater is at 240 West 44th Street in Manhattan. Second Stage’s public calendar next lists regular performances on Wednesday, Nov. 18, at 2 and 7 p.m. Its production page carries the date-by-date schedule and official ticket links.