Performing arts news
Blue Man Group takes its holiday show to Broadway, 35 years after Astor Place
Blue Man Group’s A New Holiday Surprise is on Broadway through Jan. 3. Here’s what the bigger room changes, plus how the $35 lottery and $40 rush work.

At Astor Place, there were 298 seats in the room. The Blue Men now have 1,505 to play to at the Lunt-Fontanne Theatre, where A New Holiday Surprise opened on Tuesday, Nov. 17. That was exactly 35 years after Blue Man Group opened downtown. It’s the group’s first Broadway show, and for a trio that can make a joke out of staring at one person, the extra 1,207 seats are as big a change as anything under the Christmas tree.
The company finished its Astor Place run in February 2025. The Broadway show started previews Nov. 12 and runs through Jan. 3, 2027. There’s a new holiday production, a fireplace hung with stockings, and a question anyone buying a ticket can ask about the new space. How much of the show happens in your part of the room?
A carol you can play with plumbing
Broadway had another downtown arrival this week. The Fantasticks opened Monday with a revised love story. The Blue Men built their Christmas show around a familiar way of making noise. In 2019 the Museum of the City of New York put the troupe’s original three-part PVC instrument on display after 27 years of stage use. The Broadway production carries that idea forward. Reviewing the show for New York Theater, Jonathan Mandell described the trio knocking out Christmas melodies on a network of white pipes. Caroline Cao, reviewing for New York Theatre Guide, picked out the sliding, trombone-like drumbone and big silver bells.
A tune people already know gives the Blue Men something fun to work against. You can follow the melody while you try to figure out how the arrangement comes out of a piece of plumbing. The same curiosity is there when paint hits a drum and jumps off the head. Scott Adam Davis’s set puts those experiments inside a room that looks ready for a Christmas card.

What changes when the Blue Men leave the stage
The scale pays off when the action fills the room. Michaelah Reynolds’s opening-night photographs show a sweep of streamers and giant inflatable ornaments. It’s a different problem when a performer is searching the orchestra for a volunteer. Cao reported that the production uses a live camera feed for those trips into the audience. From farther back, following the joke can mean watching the screen to see what’s happening somewhere below you.
That makes the seat disclosure matter. Broadway Direct’s $35 digital lottery can assign partial-view seats. The $40 in-person rush comes with the same possibility. Four tickets would be $140 through the lottery or $160 through rush at the posted rates. The lottery takes an online entry and gives winners an hour to pay. Rush takes a trip to the box office. Neither lets you pick where you’ll sit.

The 11 a.m. matinee changes the rush line
For most performances, rush starts when the box office opens that day. For an 11 a.m. show, rush goes on sale the day before. For Saturday’s Nov. 21 matinee, that puts the box office trip on Friday. Lottery entrants should read the cutoff on the listing for their own performance. The seller listed Thursday at 3 p.m. as the deadline for Friday’s 7 p.m. show during opening week.
Broadway Direct lists about 90 minutes without an intermission, recommends the show for ages 3 and up, and flags flashing and strobe-like lights. For that 11 a.m. matinee, the listed runtime puts you back on West 46th Street around 12:30 p.m.