United StatesSaved

Pop culture news

Now You See Me Live brings four kinds of magic to Broadway

The Four Horsemen’s Broadway show runs 90 minutes at the Al Hirschfeld. Meet the performers and see why the advertised $42 lottery ticket costs $48.

The Al Hirschfeld Theatre auditorium with a red stage curtain and draped walls.
Inside the Al Hirschfeld Theatre on Nov. 12, 2025, during the run of Moulin Rouge!. The theater now hosts Now You See Me Live. Resized for the web. Epicgenius ↗ · CC BY-SA 4.0

A movie can cut to the close-up whenever it wants. The stage version of Now You See Me has to give somebody in the back of the Al Hirschfeld Theatre a reason to keep watching. The Broadway production borrows the Four Horsemen from the Lionsgate films and divides the work among four performers, including a mentalist and an escape artist.

Now You See Me Live began performances Nov. 11 and officially opened Nov. 13, according to the Broadway League’s Internet Broadway Database. The holiday run is scheduled through Jan. 3. The production lists 90 minutes without an intermission and recommends it for ages five and up.

Follow the performers

Gabriella Lester is the escapologist, and Matthew Pomeroy is the mentalist. Darcy Oake and James More are the illusionists. That division of labor is a clue to the show’s rhythm. A big illusion gives the whole theater an image to watch. Mentalism can turn a choice by one person into a story everyone in the room can follow. An escape needs an audience to understand what’s holding the performer in place.

The idea had an earlier life in Sydney. The Sydney Opera House presented the show with Tim Lawson and Simon Painter, the team associated with The Illusionists. The Opera House listed escapologist Andrew Basso there. The Broadway version gives that specialty to Lester. Her casting is one reason a clip from an earlier run may show someone doing a different act. Associated Press reporting from the Broadway run describes an evening that also includes close-up magic, card work and comedy.

This is another holiday production moving a familiar act into a Broadway house. Blue Man Group’s Broadway debut took a club-scale show into a bigger theater, while the Horsemen came from movies and a touring stage production. In both rooms, where the audience looks is part of the show.

The price that matters is at checkout

The Broadway League advertises a limited $42 digital lottery at Lucky Seat. The operator’s terms explain that $42 already includes a $3 facility fee and that a separate $6 Lucky Seat charge is added at checkout. A winning entry can buy up to two tickets, so the stated charges put one ticket at $48 and a pair at $96. Those prices come from the lottery terms. Regular theater tickets have their own pricing.

Winning the lottery also leaves the seating location to the theater. Lucky Seat’s rules say a lottery ticket can be partial view or even standing room. That matters when the show moves from a trick small enough to fit in someone’s hands to a full-stage illusion. A viewer who needs an assigned seat or a particular sightline can make that part of the decision before buying.

The Al Hirschfeld is at 302 West 45th Street. The Broadway League has no Thanksgiving Day performance on its calendar, then lists 3 and 7:30 p.m. Friday and three Saturday shows beginning at 11 a.m. Choose a date before entering the lottery and check the deadline on the entry page.

ADVERTISED: $42 per ticket, Includes the $3 facility fee. AT CHECKOUT: $48 for one · $96 for two, Add $6 per ticket for Lucky Seat.
What a lottery winner pays. ADVERTISED: $42 per ticket, Includes the $3 facility fee. AT CHECKOUT: $48 for one · $96 for two, Add $6 per ticket for Lucky Seat. Things To Do Radar ↗
Sources